San Francisco’s
office leasing market has had 12 straight
quarters of rising rents and decreasing
vacancies. One broker predicted “rents will
creep up, and vacancy rates will inch down.”
Another San Francisco broker said “deals
over $50 per annual square foot represented
almost 28 percent of total absorption in the
last quarter.” Thus creeping rents and
inching-down vacancy seems to sum up the
entire San Francisco Bay Area office market.
Buildings where my clients were being quoted
$1.85/rsf per month, full-service a year ago
are now hanging firm at $2.25/rsf. In
Downtown Walnut Creek there are a number of
office buildings getting more than $3.00/rsf.
In Pleasanton, whereas a year ago there
might have been 15 locations able to
accommodate a 30 to 50,000 sf office user,
today there are only a third this many.
Factors helping temper an overheated office
market: companies are getting more done with
less employees due to technology; India,
China and elsewhere have accommodated tens
of millions of square feet of office users
who otherwise would have pushed U.S. rents
skyward; freeing up domestic office space;
cutbacks and downsizing is still an
ever-continuing trend (i.e. just two weeks
ago Washington Mutual announced a 900-job
reduction, Intel analysts are predicting
more than 10,000 layoffs, HP announced
large-scale consolidations, etc.); the
residential real estate industry, including
mortgage, title and other related
sub-industries is undergoing a
slowdown-layoff mode.
"The office
environment continues to evolve. Young
people do not want to work in a sea of
cubes. There’s a very negative association,”
according to Christine Barber, Knoll’s
director of workplace research. “Office work
spaces keep getting smaller and privacy
scarcer. Some furniture designers are
radically changing the cube in ways that
provide privacy without closing workers in,
while others are doing away with enclosures
altogether to keep Generation Y happy. In
one new version of the cubicle, curvilinear
panels of translucent glass with sliding
doors and windows surround workers with
light while screening out distractions.
There are enough amenities inside these
bright little spaces to coax even
recalcitrant managers out of dry-walled
offices” … “squeeze is continuing. The
average middle manager’s workspace shrank by
more than 16 percent in an eight-year period
through 2002, to 126 square feet. Clerical
staff lost 4 percent, ending up with an
average of 66 square feet according to the
International Facility Management
Association. Today’s corporations are
equally cost-conscious, but they are
changing even faster than when cubicles were
novel. Technology has made workers far more
mobile and more work is done
collaboratively. “Scootable” furnishings are
all the rage. Some organizations also are
looking for spaces that make employees
happier and more productive because
competition is increasing for so-called
knowledge workers, researchers, planners,
programmers, engineers and the like.
Industry research suggests the key to a
sense of privacy is not isolation but
control over one’s environment.” Contra
Costa Times
“Two-thirds of
Building Owners, Managers Unprepared for
Pandemic. While property managers can’t stop
the global spreading of an infectious
disease, preventative steps can help their
clients stay functioning during an outbreak.
Impacts on business include having 40
percent of the marketplace out, supply and
delivery chain disruptions and disruptions
to health care operations. Despite a cutback
in operations, building owners and managers
have the unique ability to control a
perimeter and maintain regulated operations
while educating their tenants,” California
Real Estate Journal (6/12/06). Building
Owners and Managers Association (BOMA) also
recommends establishing sick tenant
protocols, setting up lobby handwashing
stations, and possibly quarantining entire
floors. Owners and managers should also make
plans for critical staff members to work
off-site in the event an entire building is
closed. Building owners and managers aren’t
necessarily in the clear once a pandemic
abates. Tenants may be unwilling to return
to the property unless the building manager
carries out a strict sanitization campaign.
OSHA guidelines say that tenants are legally
entitled to break their lease if a building
is deemed hazardous. Most office leases
contain so-called ‘quiet enjoyment’ clauses
requiring landlords to ensure that the space
isn’t hazardous. These clauses can apply to
any number of hazardous conditions that
would impact an office tenant.” National
Real Estate Investor (June 2006)
Last week I
stumbled on a 40,000 sf office tour I did
back in May 2, 2000. Downtown Oakland Class
B rents were $3.33/rsf, Emeryville Class A
was $4/rsf nnn (close to $5/rsf fully
serviced) and if memory serves me, San
Francisco rents on an annual basis were
$70-100/sf plus stock warrants and your
firstborn. Of course, gas was a bargain back
then so it is all relative …
Deals &
Rumors: In Pleasanton, Robert
Half sublet 35,000 sf at 4055 Hopyard, and
in next-door Dublin, Taleo Corp.
leased 35,000 sf at 4140 Dublin Blvd. Up the
I-680 in San Ramon, Reply, Inc. is
rumored to be leasing 15,000 sf at Bishop
Ranch 15, and BenefitStreet has been out for
35 to 40,000 sf along the I-680 Corridor. In
Walnut Creek I leased Regency Retail
11,000 sf of office space at 2999 Oak Road.
Up in Concord, Tickets.com is rumored to
relocating to 25,000 sf at 2400 Bisso Lane.
Jumping up to Vacaville, State Compensation
Insurance Fund purchased 32 acres in Vaca
Valley Business Park for a future 430,000 sf
office campus. In Emeryville, Kaiser
took 70,000 sf at 2100 Powell Street, while
in Oakland, Keenan & Associates
leased 13,000 sf at 1111 Broadway and
Kaiperm Federal Credit Union took 19,000 sf
at 2101 Broadway. Moving down the I-680, in
Fremont, Bay Area School for
Independent Study leased 32,000 sf at 300
Kearney St. and MicroFluidic Systems took
18,000 sf of R&D space at 47790 Westinghouse
Dr. The big news in Newark is Sun
selling its 1.4 million sf Newark campus to
BioMed Realty Trust for $215 million.
Jumping across the Bay, Google will be
purchasing its 1 million sf headquarters in
Mountain View for $319 million. In
Palo Alto, Thoits Law Firm leased 15,000
sf at 1 and 2 Palo Alto Square. In South
San Francisco, Genentech leased 121,000
sf for a build-to-suit at 1 DNA Way. In
San Francisco, United Airlines is
reportedly looking around for 150,000 sf;
GSA leased 31,000 sf at 160 Spear St.;
MicroTek took 17,000 sf at 350 Bush St.;
Mypoints leased 12,000 sf at 188
Embarcadero; Riptopia inked 10,000 sf at 901
Battery; Vontu leased 21,000 sf at 475
Sansome St.; Bellamax took 13,000 sf at 388
Market St.; Zoom Systems leased 15,000 sf at
625 Second St.; Hines is rumored to be selling the 650,000 sf 560 Mission St.
building which is leased to JP Morgan Chase
for $700/sf; Hands On Mobile expanded to
28,000 sf at 580 California St.; California
Savings Bank sublet 33,000 sf at 345
California St., and lastly, Friedman
Fleisher & Lowe took 21,000 sf at One
Maritime Plaza.
The trade-off
between corporate space flexibility and cost
– “Nearly 40 percent of respondents to The
Boston Consulting Group’s (BCG) 2005 study
of real estate executives said that their
five-year projections for space demand were
typically off by more than 100 percent due
to new businesses, shift in market demand
and inaccurate forecasting methods. The
inability to accurately predict space needs
is a key driver in the demand for lease
options. In fact, all 16 Fortune 500
corporate real estate executives in BCG’s
survey indicated that they were willing to
pay extra for flexibility. Similarly, a
recent research report from CoreNet Global
titled “Portfolio Optimization Flexibility”
found that 93 percent of 48 real estate
executives surveyed were also willing to pay
for lease options. In 2004, a similar
CoreNet survey found that only 65 percent of
respondents were willing to pay for
flexibility … seven out of 10 respondents
feel that a lease with flexibility is worth
as much as 5 percent more than one without
it.” However, owners offering flexibility
can be penalized by the lending and
investment community. Early terminations and
space contractions can be onerous to owners.
National Real Estate Investor (June
2006)
During the past
five years, housing was in high demand and
there were a number of office buildings
which were bulldozed to accommodate new
residential development. I was involved in
several office sales, including selling the
former four-acre IBEW headquarters in Walnut
Creek on what now sits 54 single-family
residences. I sold 7 acres in Concord and
the former Systron headquarters is being
transformed into 76 single-family dwellings.
Housing commanded a 200 to 300 percent
premium over what the land would have sold
for as an office site. This phenomenon is
now changing, as the condo and residential
market in general has cooled down. Interest
rate increases have diminished demand and
construction costs have soared, while at the
same time office submarkets throughout the
Bay Area have begun to rebound. As summed up
in the San Francisco Business Times
(June 23, 2006) “You could make the argument
that an office site is worth more than a
residential site in today’s market,” said
developer Robert Birmingham, whose site at
201 Second St. in San Francisco is entitled
for both housing and office.
“Total job
growth in the East Bay over the past year
far outstripped employment gains in all of
California and the Bay Area. ‘The job market
in the East Bay is becoming the envy of the
Bay Area, and has become one of the job
growth leaders in all of California,’ said
Scott Anderson, an economist with San
Francisco-based Wells Fargo Bank. ‘The East
Bay also outgained other large urban centers
in California, including Los Angeles,
Sacramento, San Diego, Orange, Riverside-San
Bernardino, Stockton, Stanislaus and Fresno
counties, both in private industry jobs and
total jobs.’” Contra Costa Times
(6/17/06)
“New earthquake
models show that the seismic waves of an
earthquake may be at least 25-percent less
intense than previously thought. This new
discovery could have a direct impact on
building codes in California and the Pacific
Northwest. Should the findings hold true,
billions of dollars in retrofit projects to
keep buildings standing in an earthquake may
no longer be needed. Many scientists and
engineers are hesitant to relax building
codes despite the new information, choosing
to err on the side of building safety.”
Buildings (June 2006)
In Real
Estate Forum (June 2006), there were
several quotes I believe very applicable to
our Northern California office markets, but
were stated about Southern California.
“Anthony Manos, SVP Trizec Properties, has a
message for office tenants in the area: Do a
deal as soon as possible, or you may lose
the space you want. And be prepared to pay
higher rents … Tenants are about to
experience ‘sticker shock’ in the coming
months. Construction costs are at all-time
highs and to replicate the assets that we
have is very expensive. Rental rates are not
going to stay static; they are on the move
and they are going to move dramatically.
Tenants must move quickly or they are going
to lose the opportunity,” he says. Now
please remember this was spoken by a
landlord, but many of us representing
Northern California office tenants fear this
same trend is coming our way. However, we
have seen some landlords much too aggressive
in their pricing, raising asking rents too
high too soon, while at the same time, there
are tenants out there overly ambitious in
their lease concession requests. It is often
up to the astute brokers on each side to
bring market reality into the picture.
Business 2.0
(June 2006) ranked 2,000 technology
companies which have been publicly traded on
a U.S. stock exchange for at least three
years, have a market cap of at least $50
million, and have had positive operating
cash flow over the past 12 months. The
ranking was based on profit, operating cash
flow and 12 month stock return. While most
companies were U.S. based, there were
finalists from China, Russia and Israel. Out
of the Top 100, 23 are based in the San
Francisco Bay Area (in spite of our
exorbitant housing prices, state tax
policies and lack of municipal snow plows
…)!
Our son, Jordan,
recently turned 9, and looking at him a few
weeks ago in a dress shirt and tie gave me
mixed feelings. On the one hand, I am
incredibly proud of who he is, and how he is
maturing. His school grades are over the
top, he loves to read for hours on end, yet
he will drop the book to go bike riding,
play baseball, or just hang out with his
friends. Those of you have been where I
currently am might identify with the mixed
feelings. I was almost in tears writing this
portion of my newsletter, because spending
time with my kids, doing things together
daily, being the mentor, role model, friend
and parent is a role that is ever-evolving
and while I consciously treasure today’s
moments, I’m also aware that there will come
a time far too soon where he would rather be
with his buddies than hang out with dad.
College, empty-nester all flash through my
mind as I watch Jordan grow into a young man
… enough of that … Jordan finished up his
Little League Season with hitting a string
of triples and great fielding. He and his
almost-four-year-old sister, Madison, have
been spending a lot of time at Lake Tahoe,
where they have gone bike riding along the
Lake. Little Madison has even pedaled her
tiny bike along the Truckee River,
surprising her parents with the stamina to
endure a one-hour ride. They’ve gone several
times to the Reno waterslides and have built
some pretty incredible sandcastles at the
beaches of Lake Tahoe. To see photos of
their recent adventures, please go to
www.officetimes.com/JMAug2006.htm.
On behalf of my
family and our team here at Colliers we hope
you have a terrific summer!